From What I've Seen, You're Just One More Hand-Me-Down
©Rachel C
Do you ever wonder if people just give up on love? I mean, literally, just give it up. Like giving up baseball or art, or giving up driving or giving up golf. Do you think people can love someone, something, but just let it go? They literally, despite loving it, despite caring how it is, how it deals with the sudden change, how it survives without them, do you think that people can just drop it like an old habit, one they think is time to quit? For some reason, that doesn’t seem illogical to me. For some reason, I can see someone doing that, living that way, knowing it’s wrong, it’s hard, but doing it anyway. I can see a man love a woman; I can see him realize there is a choice to make, and instead of choosing to make the relationship—whether or not it was working in the first place—he gives up on love and walks away. Maybe I can see that because my mother was given up on, my sister, my best friend, I was given up on. Maybe that is how you explain what has happened, maybe we were just pigeonholed, just let go.
As a writer, I feel like the concept works well for a plot, for a storyline, and a character. I guess because I have never been on the romantic side of a failed relationship, I can’t understand how wrong it is for that to actually happen. I can’t understand that, to be given up is to be broken up, to be broken in, and to be hurt. I don’t think I can understand that, even though I was broken in, pulled apart, left with holes where my father didn’t bother to suture his incisions. Because, my father gave up; he gave up and I can see how tormented my mother is, how broken my sister is, how numb I’ve been left.
Maybe I am wrong. Maybe what has happened wasn’t a man giving up on something he loved. Maybe the difference is that he never loved us, he never wanted us, and he is bitter all this time for taking one road instead of the other—taking the wife-and-kids expressway instead of the degree-and-career city street. So, I guess if that were the case, I guess if it’s not exactly giving up, I don’t understand anything at all....
When my parents first separated, I had a name for the way I felt. I felt like a hand-me-down, juggled between two people, treated like old news, no body really wanting me, but being forced to wear me for lack of anything new. A hand-me-down, and not even one shuffled through the same family. The kind you find at The Salvation Army or Good Will, the kind that has a strange scent from years in closets and boxes, the kind that went out-of-style and won’t come back in, the kind of stereotypical homeless people. That feeling, and the bitterness attached to it, sticks. Maybe unsuspectingly, but you feel trampled on one morning, or you smell ancient fabric the next; and everyday you thought you’d moved on, you find you’re less than one step closer—you’re barely out of the door. That feeling retraces its footprints through your heart, it makes your head hurt, your stomach ache. It makes you wonder if you belong. Honestly, you don’t. Hand-me-downs are old clothing: out-of-style, embarrassing to wear, cheap. Hand-me-downs belong in an aluminum trashcan, lid sealed tight.
I wished that I wouldn’t feel so lonely, the only hand-me-down in a closet full of brand new clothes—tags still attached. But, there was no place to go were I could be with others of my kind. There was no Salvation Army for adolescent hand-me-downs—at least not one I was willing to find. If I wanted a room full of used clothing, there was a price I had to pay. Rip a seam, get a stain, some sort of damage to be returned to the storefront with the other second hand fashions. But, I didn’t believe in slicing myself open, especially for attention, especially to feel comforted. I always figured having a hole would add a draft to my already cold interior. Ripping myself apart would just give me something new to cry over. So I was lonely, I was a lonely hand-me-down; no one understood the pain in being worn by more than one person, the fear in being thrown away, or the ache in hanging around waiting for someone to pick me off the self. Pick me up, shake me out, wash me off, and slip me over their warm body. There were some attempts, to give me a closet and a body to belong to, but, true to second hand nature, I found myself in the waste basket once again.
Hand-me-downs happen, I think, because the first time owner gives up on caring for the garment. They have worn out the fabric and are tired of washing, drying, folding, and hanging it. They are tired of maintaining it. So they go out and find a fresh piece. New, more appropriate for the changing times, and they use that as an excuse to pull the old one from its place in the closet and drop it in the trash. The good owners, the ones with big hearts, they give their used garments to stores that will discount the price and disregard the label and throw the thing in a bin to be rifled through. The ones to be feared in the world of hand-me-downs are the ones that give up entirely and don’t bother to pack the garment in a box. They mistake it for an old rag, use it to clean up their messes; or they just wad it into a ball and toss it to the garbage with food wrappers and used Kleenex. The feeling is the same, for the hand-me-downs. Used, abused, and disposed of. Trampled, stained, torn and tattered, tossed around like a cheap sock. Even if they eventually find somewhere to belong, it never lasts, not the way they would want to, and hand-me-downs become bitter. Hand-me-downs wall off, break away from the rest of the closet, and blame the world for the way they’ve been treated, for the way they feel.
It’s never really their fault, being tossed around and worn out, because, if it were up to hand-me-downs, they would remain in that first closet interminably, worn by that first body continually. Nothing feels so great as being picked for one person, because they like your colors, your style, the way you form to their body; nothing feels better than staying that way, form-fitting and snug, for the rest of forever with the original buyer. But, I also don’t think hand-me-downs are made resentful. I think that comes with time, with endless storefronts and never-ending buyers. I think it starts with anger toward the first to give them up, and as it happens more and more, the feeling grows and cynicism sets in. And it makes me wonder, for all those things given up despite the love and admiration they once received, if hand-me-downs are made in one moment, when that first owner drops them into the trash bag labeled “Good Will”. It makes me wonder if all it takes is that split second to question if that piece just isn’t worthy anymore. And then the hand-me-down is made, one quick moment and it’s just another item of everyday clothing—no longer that special article bought solely to make the owner feel extraordinary. If that first time, that first heart break, that first “give up” is all there is to creating a hand-me-down, than I worry that I am not actually alone. I worry that I am just one of many, one of many hand-me-down people, given up by that first love, that first chance, that first impression of what a man is supposed to be.
There is a small chance for a hand-me-down to find a permanent home on someone’s back, to no longer be second hand clothing. For the rest of us, I can’t help but wonder who will find us next; pick us up, shake us out, wash us off, and slip us on over their warm bodies, if only just to turn around and throw us away again, back on the shelf for another day. The future remains a mystery for the hand-me-downs in this world, never able to tell if that next shopper is the kind of person who gives up on love.
January 18, 2007
Author's Note: Just a number in a series of many. You know, when I said I was on to something, I think for once I was right. That's a good feeling, but it's also scary to admit. Gotta go with the good first, though, and try to hold off the fear.